Stay warm with one of our hot pies!

330-518-4064

Pie Oh My!
Pie Oh My!
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Here
  • Instagram
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Order Here
    • Instagram
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Here
  • Instagram

So Many Reasons to Keep Your Fork!

Choose one or several of our classics for the perfect dessert. NOTE: Some flavors are only available at certain times. Check our order form for availability.

Savory Breakfast Pie

$30

An egg and cream filling with spices, red and green peppers, artichokes, black olives, onions and broccoli with a blend of sharp cheddar, Swiss and Gouda cheeses in a buttery crust.

Cinnamon Scones

$5

Our almost famous cinnamon scones are mouth-watering and surprisingly moist and tender. No crumbling here!

$5 each, 2 for $8. Also available by the dozen.

Double Crust Apple

$24

Tart apples and our signature spice blend with a buttery top crust.

Dutch Apple

$24

Our most popular flavor, made with tart apples and an apple crisp-like crumble topping. Add caramel and walnuts for $4.

Banana Cream

$26

Decadent custard filling with fresh banana layers in a thick graham cracker crumb crust topped with homemade chantilly cream.  

Blueberry

$24

Fresh, sweet blueberries in a bottom crust. Choose crumble topping or top crust.

California Cheesecake

$30

Cheesecake filling on a thick graham cracker crust topped with homemade Chantilly cream, fresh kiwi (if available), blueberries, strawberries, peaches, and blackberries.

Cannoli Cream Pie

$30

Rich and creamy ricotta and mascarpone filling  in a waffle cone crumb crust topped with homemade Chantilly cream, chocolate bits, maraschino cherries and chopped pistachios.

Cherry Crumble or Cherry Almond Crumble

$24

Tart cherries with a buttery almond and oat crumble topping. Nut-free crumb topping available- please specify.

Cherry Lattice

$24

Tart cherries with a pretty lattice top crust.

Chocolate Cream

$26

Decadent chocolate cream filling in a thick chocolate cookie crust topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream and bits of dark chocolate.

Chocolate Mint

$30

Refreshing peppermint cream filling loaded with chocolate chunks in a thick chocolate cookie  crust  topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream and chopped mint chocolates.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream

$30

Decadent chocolate cream filling layered over peanut butter ganache in a thick chocolate cookie crust topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream and chopped peanut butter cups.

Coconut Cream

$26

Rich and creamy coconut custard filling in a thick graham cracker crumb or pastry crust topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream and toasted coconut.

Crustless Cranberry Walnut

$24

Great by itself or served with brunch.

Eggnog Cream

$30

Rich and creamy eggnog cream filling in a thick gingersnap cookie crumb crust topped with homemade Chantilly cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg.

Elvis Cream Pie

$30

Decadent chocolate cream filling layered fresh bananas and peanut butter ganache in a thick chocolate cookie crust topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream, chopped peanut butter cups and crushed banana chips. 

Key Lime

$26

Sweet and creamy filling with real Key lime juice in a thick graham cracker crumb crust topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream.

Lemon Meringue

$30

Sweet and tart lemon custard filling in a pastry or graham cracker crust topped with thick clouds of meringue. 

Lemon Supreme

$26

Sweet and tart lemon curd layered over a rich cream cheese filling in a pastry or thick graham cracker crumb crust topped  with homemade vanilla whipped cream.

Pecan

$26/30

Rich buttery filling crammed with Northern pecans. Add a few splashes of BOOM BOOM Bourbon for $6. The only thing that makes it better is a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top! 

Pumpkin/Dutch Pumpkin

$24/26

Sugar and spice makes this oh so nice! Dutch Pumpkin comes with a crumbly, buttery oat topping. 

Strawberry Pretzel Cream

$30

Rich and creamy filling with fresh strawberries in a thick pretzel crumb crust topped with homemade vanilla whipped cream. 

6-inch Pie

$12

A half-sized version of any pie listed on our menu. 

Meringue, Elvis, Cannoli, Cali Cheesecake and Strawberry Pretzel cream pies are $15 each, other cream pies are $13 each.

3-inch Mini Pie, one dozen minimum order

$4 -5 each

Choose up to 2 flavors and receive 6 mini pies in each flavor. Available fruit flavors: Dutch apple, cherry almond or regular crumble, peach crumble, blueberry crumble, pecan.   $4 each


Cream pie flavors: banana, chocolate, peanut butter, coconut, key lime. $4.50 each 


Elvis, Strawberry Pretzel, Cannoli, California Cheesecake, Lemon Meringue and Lemon Supreme.  $5.00 each.  


Please request quote for larger orders.

Don't see your flavor?

We will bake your favorite family recipe. 

Please call or send us a text!  330-518-4064

Do you have a question? Please leave a message for us below and we will respond within 24 hours.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Delivery Available!

                    Order a pie for meet-up or delivery!


**OUR CURRENT ORDER FORM IS FOR DECEMBER ONLY**

If you need to order outside of the holidays, please call, text or message us :)


We accept all major credit cards, Venmo, CashApp, Apple Pay and cold hard cash.


We bake custom orders on demand so we ask for at least 24 hours lead time to produce your perfect pie! 


Thank you!


Piefully yours,

Jenny xoxo

Pie, Oh My!

330-518-4064 pieohmyorders@gmail.com

Custom Orders

We ask that you give us at least 24 hours notice for custom orders. 

Copyright © 2026 Pie Oh My! - All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Order Here

Powered by

Hello, I'm Jenny! I'd love to bake for you!

Take me to the pie!